Just Get Better Jokes: Clout, Comedy, and Cancel Culture

Editor's note: This is a response piece to an editorial submitted by a valiant and brave anonymous writer entitled Implying Slavery In Pursuit of Clout.


Let's begin with the title in and of itself, because it speaks to the stunning lack of self-awareness the writer will proceed to portray throughout the rest of the editorial. What the author is attempting to do is to portray anybody who has even a slight criticism with tired, racist jokes as a clout-chaser just doing it for attention. Unfortunately this logic doesn't hold up on several points: chief of them being that everything is done for clout on social media. 


Whether you post a piece of artwork or some form of commentary, you are doing it for attention. Why else tweet out whatever inane thought you have in your head to the masses? On some base level everything put out into the world is done for validation, whether it be through retweets, likes, or comments. And AnontheAnon's picture paid that validation out in spades, with the total likes coming in at over 3,000. In two weeks it's gotten almost as many likes as a post he actually put a considerable amount of effort into, his The Producers parody. It took five months for that to hit 5,000 in comparison.



If anything, Anon himself has gotten the most clout out of the proceedings, and has done it by purposefully being controversial. It's a bit disingenuous to imply that "the eBiL essjaydoubleYOUS" are the cause of the pic's popularity. This is not some silly little image tweeted out by a 3 follower account or a shitpost uploaded anonymously to Derpibooru. Anon is an incredibly talented animator whose works have reached widespread popularity in the fandom, to the tune of some 5,000 followers. Before there was even any substantial push-back on the image it was well on its way to 1,000 likes, and those in favor of the humor were already preemptively attempting to mitigate the oncoming drama. The post below was made before I ever even laid eyes on the artwork.




The author next claims that it was mostly the complainers who were starting a "crusade" and "dragging in outsiders" to criticize the work. I have to ask: What exactly where you expecting? Should every single person who laid eyes on the art have fallen to their knees in hysterical laughter, wiping tears from their eyes and screaming, "based and red-pilled," to the heavens? Let me remind you that this was posted on Twitter, one of the largest social media sites on the planet. At this point the author isn't offering any substantive defenses: He simply hates the fact that some people found the joke unfunny. It's an affront to him that anyone couldn't have liked such a masterclass in comedy as "Applejack owns slaves and blacks like watermelons." Please laugh.


And as for those "other people dragged into it?" Surely the author means anybody who possesses a pair of functioning eyeballs, right? When you post artwork it enters the public sphere, and it has the chance to go outside of your personal ring of edgy shitposters on your marepussy Discord server. If you believe your art has enough merit to share with the world, you must also accept the fact that it won't be loved by everyone. This includes show producers like Jim Miller. Much like the BABSCon Sieg Heil and the guy who asked Celestia VA Nicole Oliver about Princess "Molestia," bronies have a bad habit of showcasing their total lack of social awareness directly to the people that create the content they enjoy. Nobody was "dragged into" reacting to that picture, the very act of posting it dragged his 5,000 followers into the drama. (Of course, having stonetoss retweet the art out to his 50K followers doesn't count, because reasons.)


And contrary to the author's claims that an outraged mob was calling for Anon to be beaten and his artwork deleted, most complaints simply amounted to "wow this is shitty." Even my own complaints were along the same vein, explaining that such tired tropes without a point or any wit or subversion was stale. It's almost as if he wanted everyone to fall to their knees in hysterics, wiping tears from their eyes while loudly proclaiming "based and red-pilled." If you don't like something they do, well you're obviously just an *insert whatever flavor-of-the-month insult you want here* who needs to just get with the epic memes. These people don't want freedom of speech, they just want to never have their ideas and beliefs challenged in any capacity.

Which leads us to the author's penultimate point: Everyone who complains about the artwork has skeletons in their closets as well. I mean yeah, no shit. Got any hay leftover from that straw-man to make pancakes for Twilight? I'm on record as saying Sweetie Belle's flank looks "like a double-wide surprise" and I would like her to "do a Robin Williams on my disco stick." Does my opinion on porn invalidate my opinion on comedy? Or is that simply a weak defense that detractors themselves don't even believe in? For example, Stuten Pimmel (who runs the BadBronyAlarmv2 account that attempted to """"expose"""" my awful deeds) doesn't actually give a shit about foalcon or pedophilia.


The same goes for many people gathering spicy screen-caps to attempt to display my apparent hypocrisy. None of these people actually give a damn about any of this, and it shows clearly. You can't beat a genuine concern about racism with a disingenuous gotcha about porn, and doing so minimizes the threat actual predators in this fandom pose to children. Equivocating two entirely different genres of media is a sloppy gamble at best. At worst its a desperate hail-mary throw to lob out when you've run out of arguments. Of course, these reactionaries who screech all day about how bad cancel culture is will immediately turn around and toss around pedophilia accusations like candy. Anybody with a brain can see the accusations are performatory, a twisted inversion of cancel culture suited to right-wing needs, and multiple people have even straight out admitted it.


So if phony claims of pedophilia and whataboutism don't hold up, what's left of the argument? Well it all comes down to the old standby that all hack comedians turn to when nobody's laughing at their room-killing humor: cOmEdY is SuBjEctIvE. Now in all seriousness that is true to some extent, but the implication in its usage here is that there are no rules to comedy and literally anything and everything is funny (or not). It's a bit insulting to the comedy greats to even casually imply that there's no objective way to say what is good comedy and what isn't. Its just a cop out, a way to deflect when people don't find edgy "jokes" as gut-bustingly hilarious as the author apparently thinks. Contrary to popular belief I enjoy racial humor as well, if its done properly. Jargon Scott's Twiggie comics are a great example of edgy jokes done well. There's usually actually a punchline, and excellent narrative and comedic timing. In comparison, AnontheAnon's """joke""" was overwhelmingly bland and lacked any substance whatsoever.


Nobody's trying to cancel you or destroy comedy or take your penis or whatever the fuck. Just get better jokes, especially if you're a content creator with a large audience. Once you take your shitposting outside of your cringy My Little 1488 group chat, you lose the right to claim that you're a victim of "cancel culture" just because other people dared to insinuate that showing a zebra gobbling down on a watermelon might not exactly make you the King of Comedy. Racist humor without any actual wit or a punchline is just racist. Put in a little more effort. I know you can do better.

Comments (43)

  1. Comedy is subjective, and you can't stop people from enjoying what they enjoy. You're either funny, or you're not, and not everyone will enjoy the same type of humor. You have a different taste and you're arrogant enough to think everyone else should share your tastes. Get over yourself.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "cOmEdY is SuBjEctIvE. Now in all seriousness that is true to some extent, but the implication in its usage here is that there are no rules to comedy and literally anything and everything is funny (or not)"

    No, the implication is that what results in you laughing at something or not is the fact that you have a brain encased in a body that was coded for by your genes, and that we don't all share your particular biological configuration, and thus what we laugh at has overlap, and can differ, and that this phenomenon in human beings is always subservient to the natural laws that caused it.

    shit take.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. and as we all know your sense of humour is something you're born with, isn't developed through upbringing and consumption, and is something that cannot be changed ever

      retard

      Delete
  3. trying to claim aj is racist is repetitive while NPC style chanting cancel-it cancel-it cancel-it for days on end afterwards is hilarious but sad. I respect black people who put in the effort and understand that this doesn't actually have an impact on my valuing of black people but on the other hand some people are really fucking stupid, and thus....

    Nigger.

    ReplyDelete
  4. No one cares whether you "know" we can "do better" retard lol. Grow a sense of humor, no one is forcing you to look at anything.

    Get over yourself and preferably get over a cliff and jump off.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It's called shock humour. It's funny because of how over-the-top it is, and it's clearly not your thing.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Shut the fuck up wootmaster. You don't GET to use my dank-ass pro-foalcon post with that sweet-ass Sweetie Belle in your cringe-ass screed. Fuck you and die. Nigger. Ass.

    ReplyDelete
  7. >Screech at people who thought it was funny or didn't care
    >"You guys are racists, bad people and you're into bad things! I have the moral high ground!"
    >Get ridiculed and given the same argument back, turns out you're just as shit if not worse
    >":OOOO!! S-strawman! S-strawman! G-get better material! Y-you're wrong!"

    Ok dude.

    ReplyDelete
  8. It was a lame joke in the first place.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nice picture though. I like the filly hiding in the tree.

      Delete
  9. Reminding people that they're not supposed to say the 'nig-word that brings the western world to its knees' is only going to make them want to say it more. If you let it upset you, it will always have power over you.

    Zebras are donkeys.

    ReplyDelete
  10. You need a life bro.

    ReplyDelete
  11. PURPLE TRANNY WAS RIGHT ABOUT YOU DICKLESS FAGGOTS IN 2012 AND IT AMUSES ME TO WATCH YOU MORONS EMBARRASS YOURSELVES IN FRONT OF WORKING ADULT PROFESSIONALS WHO VIEW THE ENTIRE FANDOM AS A QUIVERING PILE OF CRINGE!

    P
    U
    R
    P
    L
    E

    T
    R
    A
    N
    N
    Y

    I
    S

    T
    H
    E

    P
    R
    O
    P
    H
    E
    T

    O
    F

    Y
    O
    U

    C
    R
    I
    N
    G
    E

    C
    U
    C
    K
    S
    !

    ReplyDelete
  12. Get over yourself

    ReplyDelete
  13. Classic first post, but you misspelled it. It's "zigger" the height of all comedy.

    ReplyDelete
  14. >listening to a literal gay nigger

    ReplyDelete



  15. Some people ask us for Russian Escorts in Goa Every time we are in touch with dozens of these girls and just you have to call us for more details of these immense service. Check our other Services...
    Russian Call Girls in Goa
    Call Girls in Goa
    Escorts in Goa
    Escorts Service in Goa
    Female Escorts in Goa
    Escorts in Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  16. A debt of gratitude is in order for posting this information. I simply need to tell you that I simply look at your site and I discover it exceptionally fascinating and educational. I can hardly wait to peruse bunches of your posts. Culture

    ReplyDelete
  17. That is a very good tip especially to those new to the blogosphere.
    Short but very accurate info… Appreciate your sharing this one. A must read post.

    My web site - 휴게텔
    (jk)


    ReplyDelete
  18. Hello, i think that i saw you visited my website thus i came to “return the favor”.I’m trying to find things to improve my website!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!

    Have a look at my homepage;슬롯머신
    (mm)

    ReplyDelete
  19. We welcomed every one of our companions and family members and we encouraged Rupert to do likewise. Subsequently, the banquet room was amassing with individuals, my mom and Rupert's mom the most invigorated of all. Comedy Events

    ReplyDelete
  20. its funny that people grew up from throwing around the words poop and fart to be funny to throwing around the n word and tranny to be funny

    ReplyDelete
  21. I think this is among the most important information for me.
    And i am glad reading your article. But should remark on few general things,
    The website style is ideal, the articles is really nice : D.
    Good job, cheers
    온라인경마

    magosucowep

    ReplyDelete
  22. Applejack is racist

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for. ซีรี่ย์ฝรั่ง

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you for sharing valuable information and useful post. I enjoyed reading this post and nice info always.... Packers And Movers Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  25. Great Information sharing .. I am very happy to read this article .. thanks for giving us go through info.Fantastic nice. I appreciate this post. https://gogostream.co

    ReplyDelete
  26. Gibbs reflective cycle in Gibbs Model of Reflection

    gibbs reflective cycle

    Get Gibbs reflective cycle in Gibbs Model of Reflection with HND Assignment Help at an affordable price and quality delivery on time. Get a 20% DISCOUNT in Academic Help. We have qualified and experienced experts in the team to give the best online assignment help services in the UK.

    https://www.hndassignmenthelp.com/gibbs-reflective-cycle-in-gibbs-model-of-reflection/

    Contact Us at hndassignmenthelp@gmail.com | +447464884564 | www.hndassignmenthelp.com & Get 20% DISCOUNT in Academic Help.

    ReplyDelete
  27. This film isn't the thing it appears to be by its name, and crafted by a few fine specialists should be visible in the film, though the maker and essayist assumed their parts far superior to numerous best Gomovies throughout the entire existence of the film business.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Fmovies is the top website platform for movies from Tollywood, Hollywood, and Bollywood. You should definitely download movies and TV shows from this website. You may watch any movie you want online or offline at Fmovies if you don't want to spend money. Additionally, Fmovies allows you to download everything you desire.Fmovies

    ReplyDelete
  29. Putlocker is one of the many on line record sharing web sites which might be used to view leisure items, which include films and TV shows, with out charge. After Megaupload become close down, the unfastened putlocker internet site released withinside the United States in 2011 and quick grew to draw a huge range of every day visitors.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Writehw offers assignment help. Kindly contact us and visit our website for more. Thank you.
    Email: writehw@gmail.com
    Website: https://writehw.com/
    Phone: +1(857)399-2684

    ReplyDelete
  31. Delve into topics related to health, wealth, and overall well-being, and discover how they intersect with the business world.
    theglobalhues

    ReplyDelete
  32. ¡Tu blog es un cohete de agradecimiento y yo estoy volando de felicidad! Manténgase disciplinado y concentrado con Contador De Clicks: ¡cuente clics y aplaste objetivos!

    ReplyDelete
  33. I'm grateful for the sense of community and connection your blog fosters – thank you for bringing like-minded souls together! Unlock the full potential of Retro Bowl Unblocked and become the ultimate football manager!

    ReplyDelete
  34. The TikTok Color Personality Test is the same as the Color personality test; It is an online quiz asking you questions about your personality and preferences. The test will assign you a color personality type based on your answers.

    This test is for TikTok users who create their shorts on the TikTok application to know their strengths and capabilities for communicating with their followers.

    ReplyDelete